Hello dear
Welcome to Righteous Slice
At Righteous Slice, we pride ourselves on delivering a true taste of New York right in Rexburg, Idaho. Our journey began with a passion for authentic Italian ingredients, which we import to craft hand-made pizzas that delight the palate. Whether it’s our award-winning New York Cheese Slice or the mouthwatering pepperoni, every dish bursts with flavor. Our selection also features fresh, vibrant salads like the Hail Caesar and unique desserts like the Star Witness, ensuring every meal is memorable. With a warm, inviting atmosphere and attentive service, Righteous Slice is not just a restaurant; it’s a community gathering place where food and connection flourish.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Fresh Squeezed Lemonade
Bee Sting
Star Witness
Build Your Own Pizza
About
Righteous Slice
Welcome to Righteous Slice, a haven for pizza lovers nestled in the heart of Rexburg, Idaho. Located at 175 W 2nd S #100, this charming eatery has quickly gained a reputation as a go-to spot for high-quality, authentic New York-style pizza. The inviting atmosphere sets the stage for a memorable dining experience, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
As you step inside, aromas of freshly baked pizzas greet you, whetting your appetite for what’s to come. Righteous Slice is renowned for its commitment to quality, utilizing only the finest imported ingredients from Italy. Each pizza is hand-stretched and made to order, ensuring a fresh and delightful experience with every bite.
- Appetizers: Start your culinary journey with their Cheesy Garlic Bread, a harmonious blend of melted mozzarella, Romano cheese, and seasoned olive oil on perfectly baked Italian dough for just US$5.00.
- New York Pizzas: The stars of the show are undoubtedly the pizzas. The New York Cheese Slice ($3.50) is an award-winning pie that took second place in the Northwest Region of the International Pizza Challenge 2022, while the New York Pepperoni Slice ($4.00) is soon to be deemed famous, enticing even the most discerning pizza aficionados. These slices are generously topped, embodying the essence of New York's rich pizza culture.
But it’s not just about the savory offerings. The dessert menu features tempting treats like the Star Witness, a stunning star-shaped delight filled with Nutella and finished with a drizzle of warm Nutella and a sprinkle of powdered sugar, delightfully priced at US$10.00. For those with a penchant for sweet indulgence, the Hot Mess, comprising cream, sugar, Nutella, and powdered sugar at US$6.00, is an absolute must-try!
Customers rave about their experiences at Righteous Slice. Diana Peck shares, "The garlic cheese bread with marinara and the New York style pepperoni were delicious! The service is so friendly!" Tyler adds, “The absolute best pizza in all of Idaho! It’s so intensely flavorful and so so so good!” These sentiments reflect the consistent quality and service that keeps patrons returning for more.
With its split-level dining area and friendly staff, Righteous Slice doesn’t just serve great pizza; it creates an atmosphere that fosters connection and memory-making. Whether you're grabbing a slice with friends or enjoying a family meal, this pizzeria offers something for everyone.
Make sure to stop by Righteous Slice on your next visit to Rexburg. You’ll find that every dish is crafted with care and passion, promising an unforgettable pizza experience!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This was our first time here and we LOVED it! The Caesar Salad was unique and delicious, the garlic cheese bread with marinara and the New York style pepperoni were also delicious! Perfect amount of meat and cheese and the crispy crust was superb. The service is so friendly! We look forward to coming back the next time we’re in Rexburg! ”
“ The absolute best pizza in all of Idaho! They import all ingridents from Italy! The pizzas are hand made to order and 100% fresh everytime. We ordered just a standard pepperoni pizza to try for the first time and it was so delicious and flavorful! My whole family devoured the entire thing in a short sitting! It was so intensely flavorful and so so so good! I can not say enough good things about their pizza, willing to drive 45 mins everytime I want pizza it is so good! If you haven’t tried their pizza, you are surely missing out. They also have fresh squeezed lemonade! So good! And the prices were very fair for everything being imported and authentic Italian ingredients. This place can not be beat for quality, price, and service! The pizza is even good next day reheated! Please stop in and give this place a try, you won’t regret it. It also has some pretty awesome views with the second floor seating! Enjoy! I know we did! ”
“ This is the best pizza in Eastern Idaho. It's worth the drive from Idaho Falls. Great tasting sauce and the crust came out perfect. The split level dining area is nice and quiet on the upper floor. Salad was solid too. Dessert "pizza" was decadent! ”
“ I have been able to get to know Bill as a professional and as a friend. Every detail is thought about when serving customers here. The ingredients, the employees hired, and the physical atmosphere, everything is deliberate. This is by far some of the best pizza I have had over my lifetime. You will not be disappointed if you give it a try. ”
“ This place is one of my favorites to go and eat and hang with family and friends. I know every time I come here it’s an amazing experience, I make new memories, try AMAZING new pizza, and I get to share it with my loved ones. The atmosphere is super sweet, the cooks and waiters are so friendly and nice. I love the pizza it’s always so fresh and hot. 10/10 I love bringing family and friends here. ”
“ As something of a pizza snob, I’ve been to some of the best pizza shops in the US and Italy and Righteous Pizza is right up there among the best of the best. Freshest ingredients and hand-crafted pizzas by a passionate and friendly staff. Go now ! ”
“ Holy Pizza! So I’ve learned over the years that some of the best pizza places you’ll ever find are near college campuses. Makes sense. College kids and pizza are almost synonymous. My family was in Rexburg and decided to pop into Righteous Slice and I’m so glad we did! The staff was super friendly, we got to chat with the owner who was super cool, and the pizza was amazing! The pizza seems to be a superb blending of Naples-style crust with American-style toppings. The owner is very knowledgeable about the art of pizza dough (yes, it’s an art and that’s not up for debate) and has trained his staff to respect the process. When the staff recommended the Bee Sting, I was hesitant but decided to trust them. Honey on a pizza? Whelp, I’m glad I gave it a go. It was AWESOME! If you’re in the Rexburg or Idaho Falls area, Religious Slice is worth every penny. Highly, highly, highly recommend! ”
“ Absolutely delicious pizza! The food was presented very well with perfect picture quality. The service was wonderful as well! My good friend at the counter explained the menu with great clarity. Very nice people! ”